Medallion has acquired Andros. Together, we’re the largest AI-native credentialing platform in the country.Medallion has acquired Andros.Read moreRead more

Credentialing

How much does in-house credentialing really cost? Hidden costs, timelines, and how to decide (2026)

Updated November 2026

If you're weighing in-house vs. outsourced credentialing, you're probably asking some version of this:

What does it really cost to run credentialing in-house, once you count everything?

It costs more than the salaries. Robert Half's 2027 Salary Guide puts a credentialing specialist at $44,500 to $57,750 a year nationally. Much of the cost sits outside payroll, in the hours your team spends maintaining spreadsheets or software, working exceptions, and backfilling turnover, plus revenue you wait on while new providers can't bill.

In this post, we’ll compare three models: an in-house team (on spreadsheets or a self-serve tool), a traditional outsourced vendor, or an AI-native platform with expert oversight, such as Medallion. The table below compares them on cost, speed, and accountability.

In-house vs. outsourced vs. AI-native platform: how the models compare

In-house teamTraditional outsourced vendorMedallion: AI-native platform + expert oversight
Who does the work?Your staffVendor staffAI-native platform, with credentialing experts reviewing what needs judgment
Time to credential with a payerDepends on your staffingVaries by vendorAbout 7 days median (24-day average)
Contractual turnaround commitmentYour team owns turnaroundVaries; check the SLA sectionTurnaround SLAs in the MSA:
  • Initial credentialing (complete file generated): ≤3 business days
  • TJC credentialing (packet creation): ≤5 days
  • Payer enrollment (application submission): ≤10 business days
  • Licensing (application submission): ≤10 business days
  • Hospital applications (submission): ≤10 days
  • Recredentialing (completed file): delivered at least 30 days before the due date
What happens on a missed deadline?Your team absorbs itVaries; check the SLA sectionSLA credit, plus a termination right for repeated misses
Primary source verificationYour staffVaries by vendorAutomated primary source collection with human review
NCQA statusYour organization's responsibilityCheck certification statusNCQA Credentialing Certification, all 11 elements, through August 2029
RecredentialingYour team tracks deadlinesVaries by vendor99.9% completed before the deadline
ScalingOften means hiring more staffDepends on vendor capacityBuilt to help scale multi-state operations without scaling headcount
Administrative costSalaries, tool, and turnoverTypically per-provider or volume-based fees66% estimated reduction in administrative costs; 2x faster time-to-revenue, on average

What is in-house credentialing?

In-house credentialing means your own staff verifies, enrolls, and monitors your providers, using anything from spreadsheets and email to a self-serve credentialing platform. The work typically covers four related areas:

  • Primary source verification: confirming licenses, education, board certification, and work history directly with the issuing source.
  • Payer enrollment: enrolling each provider with each payer before they can bill.
  • Recredentialing: re-verifying credentials on a fixed cycle set by payer and accreditation standards.
  • Ongoing monitoring: tracking license expirations, sanctions, and exclusions between cycles.

A self-serve model is in-house credentialing with software in the middle. The tool supports key steps, and your team is still left running them.

Why a self-serve credentialing tool may not take the work off your team

Many cost comparisons treat software as the way out of in-house cost, as if buying a self-serve tool moves the work off your team.

In practice, your staff still runs the workflows, works the exceptions, and answers for a missed deadline, now with a subscription added to the budget.

Regulatory load on practices keeps growing. In MGMA's 2026 Regulatory Burden Report, 95% of practices surveyed reported more regulatory burden over the past three years. Medicare and Medicaid credentialing made its top 10 list (Physicians Practice).

Pros and cons of in-house credentialing

In-house credentialing has real advantages, which is why it's a common starting point.

ProsCons
Direct control over files and prioritiesYour team owns upkeep and the exceptions
Quick access to provider recordsProcess knowledge can leave with one employee
No per-provider vendor feesGrowth often means new headcount
Workflows your team already knowsNo contractual commitment on turnaround

Medallion is built to keep much of that control with your team. Status visibility shows where files stand, while the AI-native platform and credentialing experts take on more of the work, backed by SLAs in the MSA.

The hidden costs of in-house credentialing

None of these show up as a line item, whether your team runs on spreadsheets or a self-serve tool. Each one lands on your team's time, your hiring budget, or your providers' start dates.

1. Your team becomes the support team

Spreadsheets and self-serve tools both need an owner. Someone keeps trackers and workflows current, tracks payer and state requirement changes, and troubleshoots when a submission fails. That person can end up being a credentialing specialist whose time was meant for credentialing.

How Medallion handles it: Medallion's AI-native platform maps provider data to payer roster templates and auto-populates state-by-state licensing requirements. AI agents support data extraction, application submission, and payer follow-up, so less of that upkeep lands on your team.

2. The exceptions still land on your desk

Clean files need little attention. The cost sits in the rest: a payer asks for more documentation, or a committee flags a gap. In-house, someone on your team picks up each of those.

How Medallion handles it: Credentialing experts handle the exceptions that need judgment, so a stalled file has a named person working it. AI agents support them by monitoring payer systems and following up on applications, including calling payers for status updates, and status visibility shows your team where files stand.

3. Knowledge walks out with turnover

Credentialing know-how tends to live in people: which payer wants which form, which state board answers email. When an experienced specialist leaves or takes time off, files can slow down while someone else learns the process.

How Medallion handles it: Provider data and credentialing history live in one platform, so your process depends less on one person's inbox. Medallion holds NCQA Credentialing Certification across all 11 elements, and nearly 400 healthcare organizations and health plans run on the platform.

4. Growth can still mean hiring more headcount

In-house, your credentialing capacity is your team's capacity. Add states, payers, or a new clinic group, and the exception volume grows with it. Administrative staffing is already heavy: 40% of practices in MGMA's 2026 survey keep three or more full-time administrative staff per physician for tasks like prior authorization and denials (Physicians Practice).

How Medallion handles it: Medallion is built to help you scale multi-state operations without scaling headcount. Ivy Health scaled provider onboarding across 700+ clinics with zero additional headcount. WellBe Senior Medical cut credentialing turnaround from 30 days to 6 as it expanded across seven states.

5. Turnaround stays your team's responsibility

With spreadsheets, there's no outside commitment at all. With a self-serve tool, check what the contract commits to. If its terms cover uptime and support response times but not credentialing turnaround, whether a provider is credentialed on time stays with your team. When a file runs late, the cost lands on your budget and your providers' start dates.

How Medallion handles it: Medallion's master services agreement sets turnaround SLAs for new license requests, payer enrollment requests, and credentialing file generation. Under the MSA, missing an SLA earns a credit, and repeated misses give you the right to terminate that service and recover prepaid fees for the period after termination.

Visible vs. hidden costs of in-house credentialing at a glance

Only salaries and the software license show up as budget lines. The other six costs sit in your team's time, your hiring plans, and your providers' start dates.

CostA budget line?Who carries it in-houseWith Medallion
Credentialing staff salariesYes, on payrollYour budget: $44,500 to $57,750 per specialist (Robert Half, 2027)66% estimated reduction in administrative costs
Software license, if you use oneYesYour budgetPlatform fee
Workflow setup and upkeepNoYour credentialing staffAI-native platform support for payer templates and state requirements
Payer follow-up and status chasingNoYour credentialing staffAI agents, with expert oversight
Exceptions and committee gapsNoYour credentialing staffCredentialing experts review, with status visibility for your team
Turnover and backfillNoYour hiring budgetProvider data and history in one platform
Volume growthNoOften new headcountBuilt to help scale without scaling headcount
A missed deadlineNoYour providers' start datesSLA credits and termination rights in the MSA

What is outsourced credentialing, and how is an AI-native platform different?

Outsourced credentialing means hiring a vendor, such as a credentialing services firm, to handle some or all of the work. It moves tasks off your team, but how the work gets done, how fast, and what the vendor commits to in writing vary by vendor.

An AI-native platform with expert oversight works differently. At Medallion, the platform automates key steps of repetitive work across credentialing, licensing, and enrollment, credentialing experts review what needs judgment, and your team keeps status visibility. Turnaround commitments sit in SLAs in the MSA. Whichever model you weigh, ask the same question: which parts of the work does the contract cover?

NCQA credentialing standards and why certification affects your cost

NCQA's credentialing standards cover areas including credentialing verification, credentialing committee review, recredentialing cycle length, and ongoing monitoring (NCQA). An in-house team carries the documentation and audit work behind each of those.

Certification also changes oversight. When an NCQA-Accredited health plan or health system delegates credentialing work, it has to oversee that work, typically by reviewing a sample of the delegate's files. If the delegate holds NCQA Credentialing Accreditation or Certification, the organization may choose to forgo that audit (NCQA).

Medallion holds NCQA Credentialing Certification across all 11 elements, effective through August 2029, which can mean less audit work lands back on your team.

How to calculate what in-house credentialing really costs you

Start with salaries and any software license, then add what your team spends to keep credentialing moving. Five inputs give you a working annual total:

  1. Upkeep: hours spent maintaining trackers, configuring workflows, updating requirements, and troubleshooting, times a fully loaded hourly rate.
  2. Exception work: hours on payer follow-up, missing documents, and committee gaps.
  3. Turnover: recruiting, onboarding, and ramp time when a credentialing specialist leaves.
  4. Delayed revenue: days each new provider waits to bill, times expected daily billings, across this year's hires.
  5. The cost of a miss: what a lapsed recredentialing or late enrollment costs you, and whether any contract covers it.

Compare that total against a platform's pricing and its SLA terms. The license fee alone won't tell you which model costs less.

Five questions to pressure-test your in-house credentialing model

  • How many hours a week does your team spend maintaining spreadsheets or tools instead of credentialing?
  • Who works a stalled file, and who covers when they're out?
  • How many states and payers do you plan to add in the next year?
  • What would one lapsed recredentialing or late enrollment cost you?
  • Does any contract you hold commit to turnaround, or only to the software?

If the answers point to growing exception work and no written commitments, your in-house model likely costs more than its license suggests.

In-house vs. outsourced credentialing: which model fits?

An in-house model can work for a small, single-state organization with a stable roster and an experienced credentialing lead. The math tends to change as you grow: new states, new payers, a new service line, or the departure of the one person who knows the process. Each of those adds work for your team and raises the stakes on a missed deadline.

Your situationModel that tends to fitWhere Medallion fits
Single state, small and stable roster, experienced credentialing leadIn-house, on spreadsheets or a self-serve toolWhen you add a state or lose your credentialing lead, Medallion's platform keeps provider data and history in one place, so the process depends less on one person.
Steady volume, comfortable managing a vendor day to dayA traditional outsourced vendor, as long as its speed and quality keep meeting your needsIf speed or quality stops keeping pace, Medallion’s AI-native platform and credentialing experts help accelerate the work.
Multi-state, a growing roster, or high stakes on missed deadlinesAn AI-native platform with expert oversight and contractual SLAsThis is where Medallion is built to help: an AI-native platform, credentialing experts on the exceptions, and commitments in writing.

If you're moving from the first row toward the third, that's the time to compare your in-house cost against Medallion's platform and SLA terms.

What changes with an AI-native platform and expert oversight

Medallion pairs an AI-native platform with credentialing expert oversight and SLA-backed commitments. The platform automates key steps of repetitive work across credentialing, licensing, and enrollment. Experts review what needs judgment, and the contract spells out what happens if Medallion misses.

Medallion customers see 2x faster time-to-revenue, on average, and a 66% estimated reduction in administrative costs. As CareBridge's Steven Shterenberg, M.D., put it, Medallion helps them scale "without having to build a much larger internal credentialing team" (Medallion case studies).

Talk with our team to compare what your in-house model costs against Medallion's platform and SLA terms.

FAQ about the costs of in-house credentialing

How much does in-house credentialing cost?

It depends on your volume, state count, and staffing. Salaries are the visible part: Robert Half's 2027 Salary Guide puts a credentialing specialist at $44,500 to $57,750 a year nationally. Then add the license, staff time on upkeep and exceptions, turnover, and revenue lost while providers wait to bill. The steps under “How to calculate what in-house credentialing really costs you” walk through each input, and Medallion's team can help you run the numbers against its platform pricing.

Is credentialing software cheaper than a platform with expert oversight?

On license price, it can be. On total cost, it depends on how much work stays with your team after the software arrives. A self-serve tool still needs staff to run it, while Medallion's AI-native platform is built to take on more of that work, with experts reviewing exceptions and SLAs in the contract.

Can credentialing be fully automated?

Not end to end. Automation can speed up data collection and follow-up, but credentialing decisions carry compliance risk that calls for expert judgment. At Medallion, AI agents support automated primary source collection with human review, and credentialing specialists review each file for compliance before the committee.

What's the difference between credentialing software and an AI-native credentialing platform?

Credentialing software gives your team tools to run the process. An AI-native platform with expert oversight is built to carry more of the process itself, with AI agents supporting repetitive steps and experts reviewing exceptions. Ask any vendor which parts of the work its contract covers, Medallion included.

When should you rethink an in-house credentialing model?

Common triggers include expanding into new states, adding payers or service lines, a growing file backlog, or losing an experienced credentialing lead. If one of those is on your roadmap, run the worksheet above before your next renewal.